Gender Wage Inequality: A Core Problem in Rural Indian Economy

 In Democracy & Governance, Economics, Health & gender, HomepageSlider, Manjari Balu, TPF Analysis

Sharing is caring!

Growing unemployment rates, inadequate demand and low productivity in rural India is currently drawing significant attention particularly in view of the current economic slowdown. Debates on falling agriculture productivity and consumption in rural areas have partially ignored the gender dimension. The sexual division of labour in a rural production framework arbitrarily sets the female wages lower than men. Declining participation of women in labour force could relate to various socio-economic conditions, a sector wise analysis mirrors an intelligible dynamics of the problem.   Informal rural market already operating below the minimum wage exploits women as they are presumed to have poor bargaining power and social constraints blocking their employment migration tracks. While the dire status of marginal farmers and casual labourers are talked about, economic and social inequality across gender misses the radar.

Optimism on gender grounds rose after the wage gap between men and women started reducing in rural labour market across India. A closer examination of the wage data among rural labour reveals the complex nature of female labour wages. More importantly, the seeming reduction in  wage gap in actuality is more due to  decline in male wage rates. The overall percentage of women in rural casual labour market has seen a marginal reduction from 35 percent in 1983 to 31 percent in 2017-18. Analysis of informal casual labour market reveals a pattern of women being paid low wages and with no social security schemes resulting in decline in already poor quality of living. Significantly, economic contribution of women is grossly underestimated in the current System of National Accounts (SNA). Time Use Survey captures all unpaid activities of men and women which would be more accurate to calculate. However, the problem of valuation remains an issue, and calculation of woman’s opportunity cost in a rural household is an arduous task.

Complex pattern of decline in female work participation rate

Female Workers Participation Rate (FWPR) in rural sector declined from 32 percent in 1972-73 to 17 percent in 2017-18. Studies suggest various reasons could be responsible for a fall in proportion of women in rural work force.  According to Census India 2001 and NSSO 2010, increasing number of women migrate from one rural area to other and round 64 percent of women migrants move because of marriage. A research study in Institute of Asian Studies observed an income effect, U shaped probability curve of female participation with the log of male income in the family. This means more women were working during the times of economic distress to support the family and participation rate gradually reduced with higher income earned by the men. However, with increase in income, there is also a pattern of women working to meet the increased consumption expenditure. Education is also considered an important component contributing to reduced percentage of women in labour force. As literacy rates grow, graduate women are aspiring to get employed in skilled jobs and voluntarily withdraw from the work force. However, proportion of women in primary sector has only declined from 89.7 percent (Krishnaraj & Kanchi, 2008) in 1972 to 83.6 percent in 2004. Evidently, majority of women in rural areas are dependent on primary sector for employment, a drop to 67 percent of men dependent on primary sector for employment is due to their shift to secondary and tertiary sectors. Employment in unorganised sector is beset with low wages, an exploitation by the employers.  Moreover, absence of social security cripples the income earning capacity of women. This deliberately places women in the lower strata of rural economy leading to poor socio-economic living conditions and has a direct impact on their inability to invest in education, health and nutrition.

Women in informal sector and Poverty in rural India

India’s rural sector is characterized by a large segment of informal labour force where 90 percent of the population is either self-employed or work for casual wage. Rural areas in particular operate in an informal economy and wages are mostly determined by the labour market where women are inherently considered less productive and paid less than men.

As of 2011-12, 68 percent of female casual labourers were receiving less than National Minimum Wage of INR 122. Around 47 percent of men in rural India received less than the minimum wage indicating the unreliable nature of rural informal job market. Men, naturally with higher migration possibility, shift to informal urban sector jobs but women are left with depressed wages even as the labour demand remains high. Although the rural urban migration among women is higher than men, 60.8 per cent of women migrating to urban areas are due to marriage. As far as employment is concerned only 2.6 percent of women migrate as opposed to 52.7 percent of men. The decline in women participation in labour force is visible among educated women. Unskilled women in poor households tend to work for daily wages and have not substantially reduced from workforce. In rural India, where casual farm and nonfarm jobs are exploited it makes limited sense to use only wage gap to measure the gender equality.

Agriculture, evolved from a traditional household structure, supports if not advocates, defined gender roles and discriminates women overtly through economic means. According to the recent NSSO report unemployment rates among rural females has increased from 1.8 percent in 2004-05 to 3.8 percent in 2017-18. However, an average of 5.4 percent of women had reported to be available for additional work in PLFS survey 2017-18. Unemployment is rampant across the country in all sectors but women labour supply for casual jobs especially in poor household still remains high pushing the daily wages further down. Intense land fragmentation has increased the percentage of marginal landowners to 85 percent but the demand for labour has reduced, forcing men to migrate into other sectors. Deepening crisis in agriculture also contributes directly to low wages among residual unskilled women labourers. Effectively the ‘informal labour’ market conditions has become a trap that exploits unskilled women as they are willing to work even at a lower wage rate. In effect, an increase in participation would not guarantee a better standard of living if the market is unregulated and exploitation based on gender continues.

Why Government measures are only partially effective?

Government initiatives for the rural economy have led to various policies to increase the income levels of marginal farmers and unskilled labourers. Women participation has been prioritized in such schemes and has shown to reduce poverty among rural households. National workfare program MGNREGS provides employment on demand and has managed to attract many women to participate by claiming to offer equal wages. As the Public employment program also mandates 33 percent of labours to be women, unskilled women are largely entering into the MGNREGS program. For the financial year 2011-12, 48 percent of women are engaged in this program from all the rural districts. However, wage gap exists even in a state intervention program- calculating from Annual Report of PLFS 2017-18, men on an average are reported to earn 152 INR per day while women are paid 143 INR from the state employment guarantee program. Further, in few states like Gujarat, Tamil Nadu, Punjab, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra and Telengana casual worker’s (both male and female) wage is below the notified wage for financial year 2017-18. State programs are accused of various leakages and operational inefficiencies, yet the participation remains high indicating a much serious problem in rural labour market. An important long term issue pertaining to state run workfare program is the stagnation of skill levels in rural India.  Women participation in secondary and tertiary sector is low; a possible explanation for unskilled women labourers’ compromise for low wages is because of lack of any other alternative. Skill augmentation is prerequisite to transform from an agrarian to an industrial society. A significant effort needs to be directed in training unskilled work force in rural sector, and government employment program has to be a seasonal support system.

Skill development and Vocational Training to combat rural poverty

The national average wage difference between men and women for casual employment other than MGNREGS work is calculated to be 55.02 INR for the year 2017-18 and states like Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Tripura and Andhra Pradesh are observed to have the highest gender wage difference. Ironically, these are the states with female participation (in casual labour force) higher than the national average of 25.5 percent, implying that wages (equal wages) are not the only driving force for influencing labour participation. In rural India, while socially defined roles result in unequal wages in labour market, women’s labour does not seem to follow the traditional backward bending labour supply curve. The natural withdrawal of women from workforce is not as serious as unskilled women remaining in informal sector even with lower wages. Real problem of women in rural economy is their diminishing bargaining power and skill stagnation or non-development of any skills due to informal structure and counterproductive state measures.

 A complete free market approach would deepen the wage difference as rural women are assumed to have low skills and weak bargaining power. State intervention to engage more women in labour market should not be limited to just providing 100 days of employment. Skill enhancement, vocational training demanded by industrial and service sectors needs to be imparted in rural areas. Residual women in rural areas are reserve army of labour available and usually are exploited for reasons given above. The gender wage gap is a consequence of a faulty design by the government and dyed-in-the-wool beliefs of people; solutions lie in the state prioritising proactive measures to reform the unorganized sector and improve market accessibility for women. Unequal remuneration in informal sector is a symptom of a fragile labour market. Women labourers end up bearing weights of both market and state failure with poor skills and low wages.

Manjari Balu is a Research Analyst with The Peninsula Foundation.

Image Credit:Photo by vishu vishuma on Unsplash.

Recent Posts
  • Vishu

    Rural women is not Unskilled women. The skills is may or where may not be known to be used. it’s my point of view generally …… But Great Article…..

Leave a Comment

Retype the CAPTCHA code from the image
Change the CAPTCHA codeSpeak the CAPTCHA code

Start typing and press Enter to search

Translate »